Wright's Trial Run
Frank Lloyd Wright / Maiden Lane, San Francisco
The Ramp Before the Ramp
Frank Lloyd Wright's V.C. Morris Gift Shop, and the Sullivan door that opens it.
Some ramps merely echo the Guggenheim. This one rehearsed it. On Maiden Lane in San Francisco, behind a plain wall of brick, is a curving ramp with an actual bloodline to the museum on Fifth Avenue. It is Wright's own, and it is the one he built first.
You do not find it the way you find a store. There is no window, no goods pressed against glass, nothing to sell you from the sidewalk. There is a wall of Roman brick, quiet and blank, and set into it a single arched portal. The V.C. Morris Gift Shop at 140 Maiden Lane is the only Frank Lloyd Wright building ever built in San Francisco, a 1948 remodel of an ordinary structure for Vere Chase Morris and his wife Lillian, who sold china and crystal and silver. It is small. It is also one of the most consequential rooms Wright ever made, and it carries two of his lineages at once: Sullivan on the street, the Guggenheim inside.
Approaching on Maiden Lane. A wall of brick, and no shop window.
The Portal
A Door Out of Sullivan's Studio
Stand in front of the arch and you are looking at something Wright first saw sixty years earlier, from the inside of the office that made it. He came to Adler and Sullivan in 1887 as a young draftsman and stayed until 1893, calling Louis Sullivan his lieber Meister. He was in that studio while the Transportation Building was on the boards for the 1893 World's Columbian Exposition, and its entrance became the most talked-about doorway at the fair: the Golden Door, a Romanesque portal of receding concentric arches, gold-leafed and polychrome, refusing the classical white of everything around it.
Now look again at Maiden Lane. Wright has set a Romanesque portal of concentric brick arches into a plain wall, and the geometry is the same argument Sullivan made in Chicago: a threshold that draws you in rather than a facade that shows off. The difference is discipline. Sullivan's door was gold and green and silver; Wright's is a single tone of Roman brick, with a vertical grille to one side formed by pulling out alternate bricks. The color is gone. The idea is intact. San Francisco's own landmark designation report notes that Maiden Lane was the first time in five decades that Wright had reached for the Romanesque arch, a motif he had used often in his earliest work, which is to say in the years when Sullivan's door was still fresh in his eye. This is the Golden Door remembered by the one man in the room who would spend the rest of his life building on it.
The concentric brick arch. Sullivan's Golden Door, held to a single tone.
Brick, gate, and glass at the mouth of the tunnel.
The Threshold
Passing Through
The arch is not a facade, it is a tunnel. Half brick, half glass, it pulls you off the street and holds you for a moment in a low, dim passage before the room opens. This is Wright working compression and release the way he always did, at Taliesin, at the prairie houses, at every entry he cared about. You are made small in the tunnel so that the space beyond can feel large. Then the passage turns, the ceiling lifts, and the white room arrives all at once.
On the construction
The brick you are standing under is not holding the building up. Wright hung the entire street front as a solid brick curtain wall, a screen of his favored long, thin Roman brick laid across the face of the older structure, so the arch carries only itself. The passage is a brick barrel vault, and the concentric rings that give it the Sullivan echo are built as four recessed orders: each semicircular band of brick voussoirs is stepped back into the depth of the opening as the arch bores into the tunnel, the same way a Romanesque church portal is layered.
The vertical grille to the left is a pierced screen, every other brick simply left out and the voids backed with light, so a zipper of illumination runs down the wall after dark. A band of buff stone grounds the brickwork at the sidewalk and another caps it at the cornice, and a small red enameled tile carrying Wright's FLLW signature is set into the concrete beside the arch. Beneath the arch, a stone display ledge did the quiet selling that the missing window would have done. Wright called the whole contraption his mousetrap.
Frank Lloyd Wright's signature red tile.
Release. Through the curved glass portal with even frameless glass corner.
The Ramp
A Rehearsal for the Guggenheim
Here is where the usual story gets told a little wrong, and it is worth telling right. People say the Morris shop invented the Guggenheim ramp. It did not. Wright received the Guggenheim commission in 1943, and the museum's spiral lived on paper for years before a shovel touched New York. What Maiden Lane gave him was something the drawings could not: a ramp he could build, occupy, and walk. Morris was designed in 1948 and opened in 1949, a full decade before the Guggenheim opened in 1959. It is not the ancestor of the idea. It is the first place the idea stood up in the world.
A curving white ramp lifts off the floor and winds to a circular mezzanine. Round openings are cut through the walls. The square shell of the old building disappears behind a geometry of circles, which is exactly the problem Wright set himself here, the circle played against the square, at a scale he could hold inside one room. The architectural historian Mark Anthony Wilson has described the shop plainly as a working prototype for the Guggenheim, a trial run at smaller scale, and that is the honest word for it. Trial run. Before the quarter mile of ramp coiling seven stories over Fifth Avenue, there was this: one turn, one floor, one shop on Maiden Lane where Wright found out the thing would work.
It is not the ancestor of the idea. It is the first place the idea stood up in the world.
The Solomon R. Guggenheim Museum, New York, 1959. The ramp Wright raised to seven stories once Maiden Lane proved it would stand.
Round openings cut through the walls. The circle winning over the square.
The Ceiling
Light in Bubbles
Look up and the ceiling becomes a field of translucent plastic bubbles, a soft grid of half-orbs slung in brass tubing beneath the roof's skylights. It does not read as a ceiling with lights in it. It reads as a ceiling that is light. By day the sun falls through the skylights and the bubbles scatter it into something even and shadowless. By night a concealed source above the screen takes over, so the plane glows the same after dark as it does at noon. No fixture hangs in the room. The light simply arrives from overhead, diffuse and sourceless, and the space stays clear beneath it.
Wright had been chasing this exact effect for forty years. He first caught it in 1908 at Unity Temple, where he set twenty-five amber laylights into a coffered concrete ceiling and lit them from above, daylight by day and hidden lamps by night, a scheme he called integral because it kept the room, in his words, "space-clear." That is the same church whose compressed, low entry we just walked in the tunnel, so two of Maiden Lane's moves trace back to one building in Oak Park. The idea passed through the woven glass tubing of Johnson Wax in the late 1930s and arrived here, in 1948, as these plastic bubbles. The material travels from leaded glass to glass tube to molded plastic, and the color cools from amber to opalescent white, but the conviction never moves: the ceiling itself should be the lamp.
The built-in cases below are black walnut, made by Manuel Sandoval, who had apprenticed with Wright, and each is composed of the same circle segments as the room. Everything you touch here was drawn for this spot. Under that glowing ceiling, with the white ramp curling up on one side, the effect is less like a shop than like standing inside a shell.
Daylight through the acrylic ceiling. The glowing plane Wright first built at Unity Temple.
Wright worked in curves against the square shell. Walnut, white plaster, and diffuse light. Every surface drawn for the room.
The ramp lifting toward the mezzanine.
The Lineage
The Hinge on Maiden Lane
This is why the small shop matters more than its square footage. It is a hinge. On the street it turns back to Sullivan, to the Golden Door and the studio where Wright learned that an entrance could be an argument. Inside it turns forward to the Guggenheim, to the ramp Wright would raise to seven stories once he had proven it on one. Sullivan to Wright, made physical, in a single address you can walk in an afternoon.
Other ramps invite the Guggenheim comparison, and a few of them earn it. Maiden Lane gives us something rarer: the same hand, the same idea, the rehearsal before the performance. If you want to stand inside the Guggenheim before the Guggenheim existed, this brick tunnel off Union Square is where you go.
Looking down toward the custom and built in furniture perfect for the space.
Related on Architectoid
The ramp on Catalina: the Avalon Casino, where we first set the Guggenheim comparison.
Frank Lloyd Wright's car showroom, another little-known Wright room built around a ramp.
Frank Lloyd Wright's Unity Temple, skylights embedded into a concrete coffered ceiling.
Architectoid · Sullivan → Wright → Lautner
Comments
Post a Comment